Beyond Brew vs Four Sigmatic – Our Rating | SolidGrounds

Mushroom coffee has emerged as a popular functional beverage, with Beyond Brew and Four Sigmatic leading the market. Beyond Brew, produced by Live Conscious, offers a low-caffeine alternative with six mushroom extracts, prebiotics, probiotics, and Peruvian cacao, emphasizing digestive health and a chocolate-like flavor. Four Sigmatic, inspired by Finnish traditions, focuses on Lion’s Mane and Chaga mushrooms mixed with organic coffee, maintaining regular caffeine levels and a traditional coffee taste.

Beyond Brew price is higher than Four Sigmatic price. Both products boast adaptogenic properties and potential health benefits, including improved focus and immune support. However, they differ in taste, caffeine content, and digestive health emphasis. Consumers should consider their preferences for flavor, caffeine intake, specific health goals, and budget when choosing between these innovative mushroom coffee options. As with any supplement, consulting a healthcare professional is advisable before incorporating these products into one’s routine.

Beyond Brew vs Four Sigmatic Comparison Table

Beyond Brew vs Four Sigmatic

Beyond Brew

Four Sigmatic

Ingredients & Mushroom Varieties

(6 different mushroom extracts, plus prebiotics/probiotics)
Rating: 9/10

( From 2 to 4 mushroom varieties - including lion's mane and chaga)
Rating: 8/10

Caffeine Content

Rating: 10/10

(Contains low caffeine from coffee)
Rating: 7/10

Taste & Flavor Profile

(Decadent cacao flavor, creamy mouthfeel)
Rating: 8/10

(Smooth, full-bodied dark roast coffee taste)
Rating: 9/10

Value & Cost

($29.99 for 30 servings)
Rating: 7/10

($15.99 for 24 servings)
Rating: 8/10

Sustainability & Ethical Sourcing

 (Recyclable packaging, limited transparency)
Rating: 7/10

(Fair trade, single-origin coffee, some transparency)
Rating: 8/10

Overall Rating

Overall Rating: 8.2/10

Overall Rating: 8.0/10

Latest Price

Free Shipping at Amazon

Free Shipping at Amazon

Beyond Brew VS Four Sigmatic

Beyond Brew vs Four Sigmatic: A Comprehensive Comparison

In recent years, the wellness beverage market has seen a surge in innovative products, with mushroom coffee emerging as a particularly intriguing option. Two prominent players in this space, Beyond Brew and Four Sigmatic, have captured consumers’ attention with their unique takes on this functional beverage. This article delves into a detailed comparison of these two brands, exploring their benefits, potential drawbacks, and what sets them apart in the growing mushroom coffee market.

The Rise of Mushroom Coffee

Mushroom coffee represents a fusion of traditional coffee culture with the ancient wisdom of medicinal mushrooms. This trend aligns with the increasing consumer demand for functional beverages that offer more than just caffeine. Both Beyond Brew and Four Sigmatic have tapped into this market, but with distinct approaches.

Company Backgrounds

Beyond Brew, produced by Live Conscious, positions itself as a health-focused brand emphasizing natural ingredients for overall wellness. Their mushroom coffee alternative is part of a broader range of supplements and functional foods, reflecting a holistic approach to health.

Four Sigmatic, in contrast, draws inspiration from Finnish culture, where mushroom brewing was a traditional practice during coffee shortages. This heritage infuses their brand story with authenticity and a connection to historical practices.

Product Composition and Benefits

Beyond Brew’s formulation is more complex, featuring six organic mushroom extracts along with prebiotics, probiotics, and Peruvian cacao. This blend positions the product as a low-caffeine alternative to coffee, with added digestive health benefits. The inclusion of prebiotics and probiotics is a unique selling point, potentially appealing to consumers concerned about gut health.

Four Sigmatic takes a more focused approach, centering on two key mushrooms: Lion’s Mane and Chaga. These are blended with organic coffee, maintaining regular caffeine levels. Lion’s Mane is renowned for its potential cognitive benefits, while Chaga is prized for its antioxidant properties and potential immune support.

Taste Profile and User Experience

One of the most significant differences between these products lies in their taste profiles. Beyond Brew offers a chocolate-like flavor due to the inclusion of Peruvian cacao, which may appeal to those seeking a departure from traditional coffee taste. Four Sigmatic, however, maintains a more conventional coffee flavor without a noticeable mushroom taste, potentially making it more appealing to traditional coffee drinkers.

Health and Wellness Aspects

Both products leverage the adaptogenic properties of mushrooms, which are believed to help the body manage stress more effectively. They also offer antioxidant benefits and potential immune system support. Beyond Brew’s additional focus on digestive health through prebiotics and probiotics sets it apart in this regard.

Four Sigmatic’s use of Lion’s Mane mushroom specifically targets cognitive function enhancement, which may be particularly appealing to consumers looking for mental performance benefits.

Caffeine Content and Energy Profile

A key difference between the two products is their caffeine content. Beyond Brew positions itself as a low-caffeine alternative, which could be beneficial for those looking to reduce their caffeine intake. Four Sigmatic, maintaining regular coffee caffeine levels, might be more suitable for those accustomed to the energy boost of traditional coffee.

Both brands claim to provide a more balanced energy boost compared to traditional coffee, potentially reducing the likelihood of jitters or crashes associated with high caffeine consumption.

Pricing and Accessibility

Beyond Brew offers 30 servings in a 7 oz package, priced at $37.99 ($5.43 per ounce), positioning it as a premium product. Four Sigmatic provides a 12 oz bag for $16.14 ($1.35 per ounce), making it significantly more affordable per unit. This price difference could be a decisive factor for many consumers.

Both products are available through their respective company websites and likely through health food stores or online retailers. Subscription options may be available, potentially offering cost savings for regular users.

Environmental and Ethical Considerations

Both companies emphasize the use of organic ingredients, suggesting a commitment to environmental sustainability. Four Sigmatic highlights its global ingredient sourcing approach, which may appeal to consumers interested in diverse, high-quality ingredients. However, the environmental impact of such global sourcing could be a concern for some eco-conscious consumers.

Potential Downsides

While mushroom coffee offers numerous potential benefits, it’s important to consider possible drawbacks:

  1. Allergies: Individuals with mushroom allergies should avoid these products.
  2. Medication Interactions: Some mushroom extracts may interact with certain medications, necessitating caution and consultation with a healthcare provider.
  3. Taste Adaptation: The unique flavors might require an adjustment period for some consumers.
  4. Price: Both products, especially Beyond Brew, are more expensive than traditional coffee.
  5. Limited Research: While individual ingredients have been studied, the specific formulations lack extensive scientific backing.
  6. Caffeine Sensitivity: Four Sigmatic’s product may not be suitable for those sensitive to caffeine.


The choice between Beyond Brew and Four Sigmatic ultimately depends on individual preferences and health goals. Beyond Brew might be better suited for those seeking a low-caffeine alternative with digestive benefits and a unique flavor profile. Four Sigmatic could appeal more to traditional coffee drinkers looking for enhanced cognitive support while maintaining their caffeine intake.

Both products reflect the growing trend of functional beverages, offering consumers alternatives that align with health-conscious lifestyles. As with any dietary supplement, it’s advisable to consult with a healthcare professional before incorporating these products into your routine, especially if you have pre-existing health conditions or are taking medications.

The mushroom coffee market continues to evolve, and both Beyond Brew and Four Sigmatic are at the forefront of this innovation. As research in this area progresses, we may see even more refined and targeted formulations in the future, further expanding the options for health-conscious consumers seeking alternatives to traditional coffee.

FAQs and Answers

What are the main differences in ingredients between Beyond Brew and Four Sigmatic mushroom coffees?

The main differences in ingredients between Beyond Brew and Four Sigmatic mushroom coffees are:

Beyond Brew:

  1. Contains six different organic mushroom extracts (specific types not mentioned in the article)
  2. Includes prebiotics and probiotics
  3. Features Peruvian cacao for flavor
  4. Positioned as a low-caffeine alternative
  5. Does not contain actual coffee

Four Sigmatic:

  1. Focuses on two key mushrooms: Lion’s Mane and Chaga
  2. Mixed with organic coffee
  3. Maintains regular caffeine levels similar to traditional coffee
  4. Does not include prebiotics or probiotics
  5. Does not contain cacao

Key distinctions:

  • Beyond Brew offers a broader spectrum of mushroom extracts, while Four Sigmatic concentrates on two specific types.
  • Beyond Brew includes digestive health support with prebiotics and probiotics, which Four Sigmatic does not.
  • Beyond Brew uses cacao for flavoring and is low in caffeine, while Four Sigmatic maintains a coffee-like taste and caffeine content.
  • Four Sigmatic contains actual coffee, whereas Beyond Brew is positioned as a coffee alternative.

These differences reflect each product’s unique approach to the mushroom coffee concept, catering to different consumer preferences and health goals.

How do the caffeine levels compare between Beyond Brew, Four Sigmatic, and regular coffee?

The caffeine levels in Beyond Brew, Four Sigmatic, and regular coffee differ significantly:

  1. Beyond Brew:
  • Positioned as a low-caffeine alternative
  • Exact caffeine content is not specified in the provided information
  • Likely contains significantly less caffeine than regular coffee or Four Sigmatic
  1. Four Sigmatic:
  • Maintains regular caffeine levels similar to traditional coffee
  • Exact caffeine content is not specified, but it’s described as comparable to regular coffee
  1. Regular Coffee:
  • Typically contains about 95mg of caffeine per 8-ounce (240ml) cup
  • Caffeine content can vary based on brewing method, coffee type, and serving size


  • Beyond Brew has the lowest caffeine content among the three options
  • Four Sigmatic and regular coffee have similar caffeine levels
  • Both are likely to have significantly more caffeine than Beyond Brew

It’s important to note that the exact caffeine content for Beyond Brew and Four Sigmatic is not provided in the article. For precise caffeine levels, consumers should check the product labels or contact the manufacturers directly.

The lower caffeine content in Beyond Brew makes it suitable for those looking to reduce their caffeine intake, while Four Sigmatic offers a mushroom-enhanced option for those who prefer the caffeine boost of regular coffee.

Which product might be better for someone looking to improve their digestive health?

Beyond Brew would likely be the better choice for someone looking to improve their digestive health. Here’s why:

  1. Prebiotic and Probiotic Content:
  • Beyond Brew specifically includes prebiotics and probiotics in its formulation.
  • Prebiotics are types of fiber that feed beneficial gut bacteria.
  • Probiotics are live beneficial bacteria that can help improve gut health.
  1. Emphasis on Digestive Health:
  • The article mentions that Beyond Brew “places additional emphasis on digestive health due to its prebiotic and probiotic content.”
  • This suggests that digestive health is a key focus of the product’s design.
  1. Four Sigmatic Comparison:
  • The article doesn’t mention any specific digestive health benefits for Four Sigmatic’s product.
  • Four Sigmatic focuses more on cognitive benefits (from Lion’s Mane) and immune support (from Chaga).
  1. Broader Mushroom Spectrum:
  • Beyond Brew contains six different mushroom extracts, which may offer a wider range of potential health benefits, including digestive support.
  1. Low Caffeine Content:
  • Beyond Brew’s lower caffeine content might be gentler on the digestive system for those sensitive to caffeine.

However, it’s important to note:

  • The article doesn’t provide specific scientific evidence for the digestive health claims of either product.
  • Individual responses to these products may vary.
  • For serious digestive health concerns, it’s always best to consult with a healthcare professional.

In conclusion, while Beyond Brew appears to be the better choice for digestive health based on its ingredients and marketing focus, consumers should approach these claims with a balanced perspective and consider their individual health needs and sensitivities.

How do the taste profiles of Beyond Brew and Four Sigmatic differ?

The taste profiles of Beyond Brew and Four Sigmatic differ significantly according to the information provided in the article:

Beyond Brew:

  1. Offers a chocolate-like flavor
  2. This flavor profile is due to the inclusion of Peruvian cacao
  3. Likely tastes quite different from traditional coffee
  4. May appeal to those seeking a departure from the usual coffee taste

Four Sigmatic:

  1. Maintains a more traditional coffee flavor
  2. Does not have a noticeable mushroom taste
  3. Designed to taste similar to conventional coffee
  4. Likely to appeal to regular coffee drinkers

Key differences:

  1. Flavor base: Beyond Brew uses cacao for its primary flavor, while Four Sigmatic uses actual coffee.
  2. Similarity to coffee: Four Sigmatic aims to replicate the taste of regular coffee, while Beyond Brew offers a distinctly different flavor experience.
  3. Mushroom taste: Neither product is described as having a strong mushroom flavor, but Four Sigmatic specifically mentions the absence of a noticeable mushroom taste.
  4. Target consumer: Beyond Brew might attract those looking for a novel flavor, while Four Sigmatic targets those who enjoy traditional coffee taste but want added benefits.

It’s worth noting that taste preferences are subjective, and individual experiences may vary. The chocolate-like flavor of Beyond Brew could be a significant draw for some consumers, while others might prefer the familiar coffee taste of Four Sigmatic. The choice between the two would largely depend on personal taste preferences and whether the consumer is looking for a coffee alternative or a enhanced version of traditional coffee.

What is the price difference between Beyond Brew and Four Sigmatic, and how might this impact a consumer’s choice?

The price difference between Beyond Brew and Four Sigmatic is quite significant, which could indeed have a substantial impact on consumer choice. Let’s break down the pricing and potential implications:


  1. Beyond Brew:
  • Priced at $37.99 for a 7 oz package (30 servings)
  • Cost per ounce: $5.43
  1. Four Sigmatic:
  • Priced at $16.14 for a 12 oz bag
  • Cost per ounce: $1.35

Price Comparison:

  • Beyond Brew is approximately 4 times more expensive per ounce than Four Sigmatic.

Potential Impact on Consumer Choice:

  1. Budget Considerations:
  • Budget-conscious consumers may lean towards Four Sigmatic due to its significantly lower price point.
  • Those willing to invest more in their health supplements might be more open to trying Beyond Brew.
  1. Perceived Value:
  • Some consumers might associate the higher price of Beyond Brew with higher quality or more potent ingredients.
  • Others might question whether the additional cost of Beyond Brew justifies any potential extra benefits.
  1. Frequency of Use:
  • The price difference could affect how often consumers use the product. Four Sigmatic might be more suitable for daily consumption, while Beyond Brew might be seen as an occasional treat or supplement.
  1. Product Formulation:
  • Consumers might weigh the additional ingredients in Beyond Brew (prebiotics, probiotics, more mushroom varieties) against its higher cost.
  • Those specifically seeking these additional benefits might justify the higher price.
  1. Serving Size and Duration:
  • Consumers might consider how long each package lasts. Beyond Brew offers 30 servings in 7 oz, while Four Sigmatic’s serving count isn’t specified for the 12 oz bag.
  1. Target Market:
  • Beyond Brew’s pricing positions it as a premium product, which might appeal to a different market segment than Four Sigmatic.
  1. Trial and Switching Costs:
  • The lower price of Four Sigmatic might encourage more consumers to try mushroom coffee for the first time.
  • The higher price of Beyond Brew could be a barrier for some consumers to switch from their current coffee or supplement routine.

In conclusion, the substantial price difference is likely to be a significant factor in consumer decision-making. While some consumers will prioritize the unique formulation and potential additional benefits of Beyond Brew, others will find Four Sigmatic’s more affordable pricing more attractive, especially for regular use. The choice will ultimately depend on individual priorities regarding budget, perceived health benefits, and overall value.